Battle of Stoke Field, 16th June 1487

The last stand of Martin Schwartz and his German and Swiss Mercenaries at Stoke Field, 16th June 1487

As part of our weekend in May travelling up to Partizan in Newark which was on the Sunday we also spent Saturday as guests of Wargames Foundry where we took the day to play a rather large game of Dux Bellorum, both events reported about here on JJ's

Partizan 2018
Wargames Foundry - Devon Wargames Group Day

Following our game some of our little group decided to make up for last year's visit and complete the day by walking the nearby battlefield of Stoke Field.

Wargames Foundry - Devon Wargames Group Day 2017

The weather compared with our visit in 2017 could not have been more different and with the rain confining our visit to Stoke Church and the commemorative stone to the fallen together with a very brief look at Red Gutter the scene of bloody slaughter in the rout that followed the battle, we saw nothing of the actual field of battle.

The satellite picture below is the map of the battlefield I created using the grid references created by the good folks at the Battlefield Trust who are the guardians of British Battlefields and do great work at protecting them from the vandals of British history.

You can see Foundry Miniatures building in the centre right of the picture  on the lane leading into East Stoke.

The Fosse Way or Road can be seen in the lower right and the battlefield is bordered on the left of picture by the River Trent.

The grid points I used for our visit are circled in white and the white arrows indicate the route of our walk starting from Foundry and turning right onto the old medieval road, Humber Lane, that runs parallel to the Fosse Way and is thought to be the approach route used by the opposing armies.

The satellite picture with the Battlefield Trust references to plot our progress across the battlefield. The positions of the armies is taken from the Battlefields Trust data with the favoured positions shaded.

To further aid understanding what the pictures I took show, I have transposed the likely positions of the two armies at Stoke Field based on the data provided by the Battlefields Trust, with a link below for further reading and I have orientated my views to be either looking towards East Stoke, the River Trent, the Fosse Way or the favoured Lancastrian position

http://www.battlefieldstrust.com/resource-centre/warsoftheroses/battleview.asp?BattleFieldId=42

An out line of the battle and events leading up to it can be found in the link below.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Stoke_Field

In summary, the battle of Stoke Field was fought on 16th June 1487 and was the culmination of a campaign started by the Yorkist John de la Pole, Earl of Lincoln who fled the court of the Tudor King Henry VII and with the help of Margaret Duchess of Burgundy who supplied some 2,000 German and Swiss mercenaries, raised an army in Flanders with later additions when the force sailed to Ireland on the 4th May 1487.

It was in Dublin that Lincoln decided to validate an impostor or pretender who had been introduced to him at the start of the campaign, a young man called Lambert Simnel although that may not have been his actual name. In Dublin Simnel was crowned by the Irish nobility and clergy, Edward VI, and with their puppet pretender proclaimed the rightful King, Lincoln sailed for Lancashire, where after landing on the 4th June and a few days of manoeuvring his forces against those of Henry VII the two armies met on Stoke Field, with the Tudor/Lancastrian force now outnumbering those of Lincoln's with 12,000 Lancastrians versus 8,000 Yorkists.

Lambert Simnel proclaimed by Irish supporters of the Yorkist rebellion in 1487

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lambert_Simnel

The battle would be the culmination of the long and bitter Wars of the Roses and would finally confirm the establishment of the new Tudor dynasty on the throne of England with the Yorkist army destroyed and with most of its leaders dead on the field of battle or never heard from after it.

Point 1

We started our tour by walking back towards East Stoke from the Wargames Foundry buildings and turning right up the old medieval road, Humber Lane, the approach route likely taken by Lincoln and his army.

Today the lane turns into a muddy rutted farm track that makes its way across the open fields of the battle site.

Looking along the hedgerow on the right of Humber Lane towards the River Trent. 

Looking back towards East Stoke with Humber Lane to right of picture

Looking along Humber Lane and the slight incline towards the ridge held by the Yorkists and the Lancastrians position further on

Point 2
The weather was gloriously hot and sunny on the day we visited and the sight lines made it easy to imagine the two armies drawn up facing each other in battle array.

Looking along Humber Lane towards the position held by the Yorkists 

Point 3/4
The top of the slight ridge, known as Rampire Hill is obvious when reached offering good views out over the neighbouring countryside and a good position for any army of the period to hold.

It seems likely that the more experienced and better led Lancastrian army under the Earl of Oxford must have really hurt the Yorkist forces atop this pinnacle with accurate and punishing arrow fire to cause them to surrender the advantage it offered and charge down on to the lower ground held by Oxford's vanguard.

The centre of the Yorkist position on Rampire Hill (shaded block on the map above) looking down towards the Fosse Way running alongside the white buildings on the right

The same point above but looking along the ridge in the direction of the River Trent

Looking towards the trees and the position of 'Red Gutter' on the Yorkist right that led the routers towards the River Trent position 474224, 349768 on the map above

A Lancastrian hare occupies point 5 on the map at the T Junction at the end of Humber Lane

The hare on the move, all legs and ears

Point 5
The ground occupied by Oxford's vanguard and the area between the two armies positions was bitterly fought over as the Yorkist mercenaries fought hand to hand to break Oxford's smaller contingent but were never able to overcome them as the other Lancastrian battles under Jasper Tudor kept feeding reinforcements into the battle.

As the hand to hand fighting went on the poorly protected Irish troops were shot to pieces by accurate arrow fire from the Lancastrian archers with many of their dead at the end of the battle being described as looking like hedgehogs, their bodies being pierced by so many arrows.

The view at the junction looking at the ground held by the Lancastrians at the start of the battle

The left flank of the Lancastrian line

The view from the Lancastrian line looking uphill towards the Yorkist right along the hedge line out towards the Trent

The view to the Lancastrian right facing towards the Yorkist left with track leading to the Fosse Way in the background 

I was fortunate to visit Bosworth in September 2012 on the day the body of Richard III was discovered in a car-park in Leicester. That visit preceded the start of this blog by three months so I guess I might have to put a post together with my pictures from that day, some time.

My only collection of WOR figures produced for a Devon Wargames Group game a few years ago, but a collection I intend to return to later.

The interesting thing is that Bosworth has captured the imagination, with the death of the last English king on a battlefield and the last Plantagenet, Richard III the dastardly villain portrayed by Shakespeare, has all helped to place the battle in pole position as the final full stop on the Wars of the Roses. Stoke Field was a larger and more bloody affair than Bosworth and its effects were more crushing and final and perhaps it is time that 1487 and Stoke Field is declared the full stop of the Wars of the Roses.

Next up, Mr Steve has been on his travels and so I have I. Plus a big game of Augustus to Aurelian in the Dark Ages, and Steve M and I attended this year's Chalke Valley History Festival.

Tewkesbury Medieval Festival - July 8/9th 2017

Mr Steve reports on the Tewkesbury Medieval Festival

Their website does all the initial explaining for me:

“Tewkesbury Medieval Festival has been the high spot of Tewkesbury’s summer since 1984. It is now widely regarded as the largest free medieval gathering of its kind in Europe, and attracts re-enactors, traders and entertainers, and visitors from all over the world.

Its central attraction is a re-enactment of the Battle of Tewkesbury, on part of the site of the original 1471 battlefield. Many of the participants including wives and children live as a medieval army in authentic medieval encampments for the whole weekend.

The event features a wide range of period entertainment, including music, dance and drama as well as a collection of fascinating characters from the past. These may include barber surgeons, preachers and even the odd dragon keeper and an exhibition tent with displays from organisations specialising in different aspects of history.

The town centre is bustling with associated events and the streets are decorated with dozens of authentic medieval banners for the festival period.

Best of all, despite its size and popularity, entry to Tewkesbury Medieval Festival is free, and its hard working volunteer directors are determined to keep it that way.”

Every January for the last few years I have written this event onto my calendar (yes I still do this, none of that electronic nonsense for me) but have never gone, either its too far to go, it’s too cold, or it conflicts with club, but this year I actually went.

And I am glad I did.

First thing is, get there early, I arrived around an hour after it opened and I just managed to squeeze into the 2nd overflow car park which meant I now had a bit of a walk to get to the event (actually quite a bit), you do pay for parking (£5) but it does go towards the cost of the festival. Having never been before I had no idea what to expect or where it was being held so when I finally arrived I saw a large field stretching out in front of me filled with rows of tents. Once past the handful of hippies selling Dream interpretations and Shakra re- alignment you get to the multi-rows of tents selling everything a respectable medieval peasant who had more dung than he knew what to do with could
possibly want. Replica Weapons of all sorts, clothing for the military and the civilian, arts and crafts (I did see a very nice pottery tankard for £10), yet more weapons, more clothing etc etc.

 

Add in the areas for weapon displays, assorted dancing (mainly with sticks), period music, numerous children’s entertainment, historical information tents and of course food and drink concessions. It was a very big field.

When I was a boy you could play football in the street without armour

Various other sub-fields were festooned with medieval tents where the re-enactors put on

the usual Medieval living experience as well as being used for their camping.

My day was therefore split 50/50 between queueing for food and watching the main battle, Ok, there was also some shopping but apart from buying a bumper sticker (my other car’s a hay-cart) and deciding that I probably didn't need any more battle axes it was mainly queueing.

 360 view from the ice cream queue

Whoops! Almost forgot, I did go on an abbreviated battlefield guided tour which was excellent, I am sorry but I did not take a note of the guides name but he does regular walks of the battle throughout the year. (See below)

Our guide in front of the deer park

Myself and fifty-nine others gathered just outside the festival entrance where he outlined the events leading up to the battle, then we walked up a lane to roughly opposite the Deer Park and the Gastons fields where we stopped for a brief synopses of the battle itself, returning back to the small field by the Festival main entrance to what may have been the Bloody Meadow.

Overall very good and I intend to make a special journey later this year for the full walk and tour.

http://battlefieldstrust.com/event.asp?EventID=834&Refresh=12%2F07%2F2017+17%3A23%3A

So onto the Battle:

Queueing for ice creams meant I was late to the battle

In a field adjoining the main festival and supposedly set on part of the actual battlefield itself (oddly surprisingly missing from the previous tour) we had a recreation of the Battle of Tewksbury. We did have a distinguished compare for the day, Professor Ronald Hutton who gave a stirring description of the history and characters involved and which was suitably altered to suit the very large crowd of non-history types that had gathered, before he handed over to one of the re-enactors who covered the actual battle description.

Ronald Hutton

There were apparently 2000 re-enactors taking part and which included contingents from France, Belgium and Germany who have been coming over especially for this event for many years. (coming over here taking our re-enactors jobs!).

Some French tourists

The battle itself I found both interesting and disappointing. Firstly the shear number of people involved was super impressive, most of whom were in very shiny armour on a hot day, this was re-enactment done on a big scale and visually it looked fantastic. Worth going just to see it.

Lancastrian army

Yorkists

Unfortunately the battle followed the usual course I have seen at every re-enactment. First one group moves forward and fights, it falls back, another group advances and does the same. Both sides then move forward and they all fight. Both sides fall back, Then it starts all over again. Normally it is interspersed with cannons and Pony Club but we only had cannons this time and a lot of archers.

Yorkist archers

Despite their best efforts in the commentary I didn't believe that I was seeing a recreation of the battle of Tewkesbury however I do realise why they do it this way. Still it was well done and it was impressive.

I left before the end and so missed the Italian flag wavers who were up next. (obvious joke to be inserted here).

Overall Impression: Excellent day out and the town itself was magnificently lined throughout with appropriate flags flying from every building.

One suggestion: bring a picnic.

I can recommend the mead tent, please tell me you can see him to?

Tewkesbury Medieval Festival is usually held on the 2nd Weekend of July

http://www.tewkesburymedievalfestival.org/

This has been a day out with Mr Steve

Battle of Towton 29th March 1461

The Game of Thrones TV series is great entertainment but in my opinion the fictitious struggle for power it depicts pales in comparison to the drama of the exploits of the characters that led the factions in the bitter struggle that characterised the Wars of the Roses and that created the inspiration for the fiction.

There were perhaps no more bitter encounters and probably no larger, than the dramatic clash between the houses of York and Lancaster on the bloody, snow-covered field of Towton on Palm Sunday 1461.

Towton Battlefield Society

Battle of Towton

The battle is billed as the largest and bloodiest fought on English soil and certainly during the Wars of the Roses with modern estimates of around 25,000 combatants on each side and a death toll estimated at around 28,000 men.

As outlined in my post about Marston Moor, Carolyn and I are enjoying a week's holiday in York and, as part of that time, I planned to take a look at some nearby battle sites of which there are several in this historically important strategic part of the country and Towton is one of them.

In 1461 the conflict between the two Royal houses of York and Lancaster was entering the sixth year of a bubbling war that had effectively kicked off into open hostilities with the Yorkist victory at the First Battle of St Albans in May 1455, another six significant actions followed over the intervening years with the score running at four victories to the Yorkists and three to the Lancastrians culminating in their victory at the Second Battle of St Albans on 17th February 1461.

The conflict was starting to polarise areas of the country in support of one faction or the other and so when Edward Earl of March and the Earl of Warwick entered London two weeks after St Albans they were welcomed enthusiastically and Edward was offered and accepted the title of King of England.

However Edward did not take the crown, being well aware that King Henry VI and his determined Queen, Margaret of Anjou were still very much in the game and needing to be dealt with before he could feel secure on the throne.

Thus Edward quickly prepared his campaign to confront his enemies in the north, ordering the Duke of Norfolk to raise his forces and meet him on the road together with Warwick's forces, at Coventry, eventually bringing his army together at Doncaster.

The map taken from the information board showing the approach marches taken by the armies to Towton.

Following their victory at St Albans, but knowing that Warwick had escaped the battle with most of his army, and regrouped in London where, with the support of Norfolk and Edward and a leaning towards the Yorkist cause in the south east generally, they faced a powerful Yorkist threat that required a large Lancastrian army to be created to deal with it.

They naturally fell back to York and the area that offered the best support for their cause, with King Henry and Margaret taking up residence in the city whilst their army was built.

Meanwhile Edward marched his combined army to Pontefract Castle some twenty miles from York, detaching John Radcliffe, Lord Fitzwalter to seize and secure the crossing point on the River Aire at Ferrybridge, just a couple of miles away.

As Edward moved on Pontefract Castle, The Duke of Somerset led out the Lancastrian army from York heading to Tadcaster and then down the London Road to the little village of Towton, picking the area of high ground just south of the village as a good area to make a stand whilst ordering Lord Clifford to take his force to scout down to the River Aire and the crossing point at Ferrybridge.

The air photo of the battlefield on one of the information boards provides a good map for the route we took and the positions where we photographed the battlefield - north is the top of picture.

In essence the Battle of Towton began at the Ferrybridge crossing as the two sides encountered each other there and with the Yorkists eventually turning the Lancastrian position on the river, began a rapid pursuit back to Towton with many of the Lancastrians being cut down on that pursuit.

Point 1 -The Rockingham Arms is the first significant building seen on entering Townton from the north and York just as the Lancastrians under Somerset would have done - I wonder if he called in for a quick half!

By mid morning the two armies faced off on the high plateau that forms the Towton battlefield dropping away on the eastern and western flanks and with a shallow valley separating the northern and southern heights. On the western edge the plateau drops away more sharply leading down to the steep banked stream, Cock Beck.

Point 1 - When Carolyn and I first saw this we both exclaimed "that looks old!" - The stable block at Towton Hall

The battle was fought out on a cold windy winter day with snow falling and with the wind blowing it into the faces of the Lancastrians.

The Yorkists took full advantage of the weather to make up for the fact that they were slightly outnumbered and still waiting the arrival of the Duke of Norfolk's contingent left behind at Pontefract castle, when their leader developed a sudden illness. He was to follow on as soon as he could bringing forward any late reinforcements.

Using the snowfall and wind to cover their approach and extend the range of their bow fire the Yorkists are said to have loosed of one volley of arrows that stung the Lancastrians into a full on response back.

Point 1 - I hope the owners didn't mind a photo of this now famous landmark - Towton Hall

The Lancastrians were unable to judge the distance accurately and could not tell that the bulk of their arrows were falling short.

When their firing subsided due to their use of arrows, the Yorkists returned the fire in full measure advancing to collect the Lancastrian arrows and return them with interest. The damage caused had the effect to cause the Lancastrian line to move forward rapidly in the hope of settling matters close up and hand to hand.

Towton Hall was the scene of discovery of several skeletons relating to the battle now interred in Saxton Chuch. It may also be the site for Richard IIIs lost chapel dedicated to the battle.

The two sides came to grips along the Towton Vale with the Lancastrian right flank having the initial success in driving the opposition back up the slope. This is where the controversy over the possible Lancastrian ambush party joining the fight on this flank comes into the story, although modern accounts seem to dismiss this event happening at all.

Point 2 - Lord Dacre's Cross, acts as memorial marker for the battle alongside the B1217

However the battle deciding event was the arrival of Norfolk's troops who reinforcing the Yorkists right flank drove in the Lancastrian left flank and caused the two lines to almost rotate anticlockwise pushing the Lancastrians back on a line leading to the Cock Beck.

28th March 1461

The Yorkist push continued and when the collapse came the rout down to the stream heralded the mass slaughter that this battle is infamous for and seems confirmed by the burial mounds discovered in the field known as Bloody Meadow.

The head of the cross lay for many years in the nearby hedgerow
but was finally put back as it is today in 1928

The battle saw the characteristic brutality of nobles murdering one another that so typified this conflict and although the senior Lancastrians made good their escape to Scotland, many of the others were lost in and after the fighting including leaders such as the Earl of Northumberland and Lord Dacre.

Point 2 - The view out to the south and south east from Dacre's Cross, The Lancastrian line was set up from the road in front out to the left of picture 

The description of Lord Dacre's death describes the Lancastrian leader exhausted by the fight taking off his helmet to take a drink. Close by ran a line of elder trees from which a youth in the Yorkists ranks fired his bow putting an arrow through Dacre's neck and killing him.

The story includes tales of revenge on Dacre for having already killed the young man's father, which seems fanciful but it seems that Dacre was killed by an arrow.

Point 2 - Looking to the south west from the cross towards Castle Hill Wood where the Lancastrian ambush party lay in wait 

The other interesting aspect of this story is that Lord Dacre was said to have been buried upright astride his horse.

Poppies on a battlefield as we headed across the fields to Point 3

In the middle of the eighteenth century his tomb was partly opened and Lord Dacre's skeleton was discovered to have been buried in an upright position. In 1861 the ground adjacent to the tomb was disturbed revealing the skull of a horse and vertebrae in situ and extending downwards towards the Dacre burial. Great story! What did I say about this being more interesting than all that dragon stuff!

The view along the track to Dacre's Cross as we walked to Point 3 on the map

The battlefield of Towton is not the easiest to get access to and the Towton Battlefield Society, Natural England and the Royal Armouries are to be congratulated for having created a walk with some excellent guide panels illustrated in this post.

There was nothing like this when I visited over thirty years ago and it was a pleasant surprise.

Point 3 - In recent times these very helpful and interesting information boards have been set up around the field. Many however are not in parts of the field most of us would want to head for!

I guess my criticism, and I am sure the ridiculous laws we have in England restricting access to so much of our countryside by the public, that would like to enjoy it, probably has something to do with this, has the walk taking you away from the area of the fighting with a route along the Cock Beck back towards Towton and along the road to the Dacre monument!!

Point 3 - The view from here shows the dip in the ground known as Towton vale, to the centre right and it opening out to the Cock Beck

So as before I have adapted the information panel map and given you the route I chose to follow that led across the battlefield from Towton to Saxton taking in viewing points that allowed me to get the pictures illustrated with a description of what you are looking at.

Point 3 - Here the escarpment is quite clear as it drops off to the south west and the Cock Beck below. Point 4 or  'Bloody Meadow' is visible centre right of picture with a close up in the next but one picture below.

The features described in the accounts of the battle are easily discernible and the nature of the ground easily explains why the battle was fought the way it was, excepting that I wasn't standing on that plateau in a blinding blizzard thank goodness.

Point 3 - Looking west down the steep slope to the Cock Beck

The strongest impression I got was the steep fall away from the high ground down to Cock Beck and indeed the steep banks along the stream, all of which would have made desperate men in a hurry to get off the battlefield many clad in gear not exactly suited to rapid mobile movement more likely to be caught and butchered or be killed in the shallow water falling and being trampled on by their comrades not in the mood to stop and help.

Point 4 - With the arrival of Norfolk's force reinforcing the right flank of the Yorkist line, the effect was to turn the battle anticlockwise causing the broken Lancastrian army to flood down the slopes from left of picture in a desperate attempt to put the Beck between them and their pursuers. No quarter was given .

The other impression is that the open plateau was a perfect place to run a battle making full use of the longbow, with excellent views of the opponents lines from one side of the Towton vale to the other.

Thus we come to the deciding effects of visibility, wind velocity and direction that made the key difference between the two sides before Norfolk's fresh reinforcements arrived to seal the fate of the Lancastrian army.

Point 5 - Looking north, north-east from the Yorkist line with the Lancastrians coming over the ridge-top left to right centre.
Extreme right is where Norfolk would have arrived to reinforce the Yorkist line

I walk battlefields to inform my hobby and I have a mind to play Wars of the Roses scenarios going forward and it seems to me that a rule set that captures and models these aspects that typified Towton and other battles of this period are key to getting that simulation aspect into the game.

Point 5  - Looking east along the field line along  which the Yorkists would have met the Lancastrians

Point 5 - Looking out from the western end of the Yorkist line towards Castle Hill wood and the direction from which the Lancastrian ambush party attacked, if it actually did!

Towton battlefield is one of those battle sights that carries a gloomy aura about it and I was certainly conscious of it whilst walking among its fields.

Point 5 - Looking north up the road towards Towton with the Towton vale clearly visible leading down to the Cock Beck on the left of picture

In recent times more has been discovered about the battle with a forensic look at the effects of battle on the skeletons of men killed in the fighting together with a better understanding of the ages and health of those men up to the time they died. Having seen the pictures and descriptions of the horrific wounds they suffered the descriptions of the brutal nature of this battle really don't do the nature of these soldiers deaths full justice.

Point 6 - Lord Dacre's tomb at All Saints Church, Saxton

Some of those soldiers remains were newly discovered and were later interred in the cemetery of All Saints Church in Saxton alongside the tomb of Lord Dacre

The Dacre coat of arms barely visible after the intervening centuries

Dacre's Tomb is badly eroded by the centuries of weather, but some of the Latin inscription is still visible and because my Latin is a little rusty I understand it to be;

"Here lies Ralph, Lord of Dacre and Gilsand , a true soldier, valiant in battle in the service of King Henry VI, who died on Palm Sunday, 29 March 1461, on whose soul may God have mercy."

A more recent burial from the battle marking the interred remains of the dead discovered at Towton Hall in 1996

"Here lie the remains of unknown soldiers found at Towton Hall and killed at the Battle of Towton
Palm Sunday 29th March 1461 erected by the Towton Battlefield Society 23-4-2005.
Remember and pray for all those who died."

So next up we are off to the tumultuous campaign of 1066 and the battles of Fulford and Stamford Bridge, before moving on to look at some of the great things to see in York.