Nailing the Colours, Battle of the Vanguards - Kiss Me, Hardy

Last Saturday I spent a very pleasant day running two Kiss Me Hardy games of my scenario 'Nailing the Colours, Battle of the Vanguards' recreating the fight between the Batavian-Dutch and British vanguards at Camperdown.

Devon Wargames Group - Clotted Lard 2024

The Battle of Camperdown was a story of two separate actions, one between the British and Dutch Van Squadrons and the other between the British and Dutch rear squadrons, with the Dutch centre attempting to support both and not really achieving either, thus while the Dutch rearguard was overwhelmed by British numbers and guns, a more equal combat was being contested to the north. 

There the combat was centred around the two flagships, Duncan's Venerable engaging De Winter's Vrijheid eighteen minutes after Monarch broke the line to the south which saw a separate fight take place between the opposing ships that lasted about an hour until reinforcements from Onslow's squadron, Director 64-guns, Powerful 74-guns and Veteran 64-guns joined Duncan's ships to seal the British victory.

The highlighted portion of this view of the battle just before it commenced indicates the portion of the Battle of Camperdown, Nailing the Colours represents

At the height of the combat, the colours and signal flags on Venerable were brought down by cannon fire. To ensure that there was no suggestion that the flagship had surrendered, a sailor named Jack Crawford scrambled to the top of the mainmast and replaced them as the battle raged beneath him. 

The battle between the British and Dutch flagships, Venerable and Vrijheid as depicted by Thomas Whitcombe, with the latter about to become dismasted in this exchange of fire.

Casualties in the battle were very heavy on both sides, attributed to the Dutch tactics, mirrored by the British, of firing at the enemy hulls rather than attempting to disable their masts and rigging as with other continental navies, with the worst hit of the British ships being Ardent 64-guns with 148 casualties, and Belliqueux 64-guns under Cpt John Inglis with 103 casualties.

In total, British losses were recorded, depending on your sources, after the battle as somewhere between 203 to 228 killed and 622 and 812 wounded, including 16 of the latter who subsequently died. Many of the British ships were badly damaged, taking on large quantities of water through damaged hulls. One of the worst hit was Venerable, which had to be completely dismantled and reconstructed after returning to Britain before the ship was ready for active service again.

Batavian-Dutch losses were later reported as 540 men killed and 620 wounded, with Vrijheid the worst hit with the loss of almost half of its total complement. Among the losses were Captain Hinxt of Beschermer and Captain Holland of Wassenaar, both of whom were killed early in the battle. Also lost were Captain Van Rossum of Vrijheid, who was struck in the thigh by a cannonball and died shortly afterwards from the effects of the wound. There were also large numbers of wounded among the Batavian-Dutch fleet, including Rear-Admiral Story.

Admiral Duncan receiving the surrender from Vice-admiral De Winter at Camperdown - Daniel-Orme

One of the few Dutch officers to escape injury or death was De Winter himself, who later commented

"It is a matter of marvel that two such gigantic objects as Admiral Duncan and myself should have escaped the general carnage of this day."

The scenario focusses on the attack by the British Vanguard under Admiral Adam Duncan before the arrival of elements of the British leeward division under Vice Admiral Onslow after they having quickly overwhelmed the Batavian rear and driven off the centre.

The table set-up as depicted in the table plan, with the Batavian van in battle-line spaced 9cm between their bases and their light ships looking to cover the gaps.

Camperdown like Trafalgar offers itself up to being broken down into separate actions that are squadron on squadron fights within the context of the larger battle, and if so inclined this scenario could easily be extended through to the arrival of the three British reinforcements should players have the time to fight it to that point.

Admiral Duncan's British squadron are set up in their line of bearing each aiming for a gap in the Batavian line having been signalled ten minutes earlier to break the enemy line and to engage closely.

That said I was content to play this in its basic format to play test the concept and learn any changes that would improve things, such as bringing the British closer in the second game and moving the Batavian line closer to the centre of the table thus shortening the British approach to bring on the fighting more quickly and to allow the Batavian's more room to manoeuvre to deal with British ships breaking in among their two lines.

The table all set up for our game at Clotted Lard - Let battle commence

The Batavian ships are rated as Sans Culottes in KMH, the usual rating for French, but their tactics were somewhat dissimilar from the French as described in the accounts above in that they preferred to reserve their fire to medium range or closer, concentrating on hitting the enemy hulls rather that attacking their rigging, a point noted by British observers who had been on the receiving end and the casualties it caused, quite unlike battles with the French or Spanish.

The example of the ship record card for the Batavian flagship Vrijheid rates them as Elite Sans Culottes, gaining the extra dice, but no additions for long and extreme range rigging shots

To better model the Batavian tactics, I removed the rigging shot bonus dice added to Sans Culottes crews and raised all the Batavian squadron, except Vrijheid, to elite for firing but, again excepting Vrijheid, to average for all other occasions such as sailing and morale.

The Vrijheid, already being an elite ship, didn't gain from the change but given her flagship status and the more robust morale rating that implies already makes her less likely to succumb to British firing than other ships within her squadron, and better able to stay in the fight as she did historically whilst also very capable of dishing out a lot of hurt to any British ship that comes alongside.

The British van squadron are ready to advance.

The two games were quite different in that in the first game the British got the rub of the chit draw often managing to get their fire chit out first and before their movement whilst also succeeding in getting slightly over half their ships to break through the enemy line and issuing raking fire as they did so.

In the opening exchanges of our first game, extraordinarily, the Venerable has failed to break the Batavian line and has turned away to begin a short range exchange of broadsides with Rear-admiral Story's Staten Generaal. Closest to camera the 74-gun Triumph opens up with bow-chasers on the 64-gun Wassenaer.

However this British success was offset by an unfortunate roll for 'Getting Choppy' that was later reversed but that caused these successful British attacks to be reduced to partial broadsides and thus much less damaging than they might have otherwise been.

Similarly the choppy waters didn't do the Batavians any favours, with their fire to leeward already reduced to partial, recreating the comments of many of their captains reporting that the conditions forced them to close their gunports on that side, perhaps related to their ships being of much shallower draft, but with the choppy rolling conditions rolled for further reducing their firing to partial, partial broadsides.

The typical rolling attack of a British breaking the line manoeuvre in line of bearing pinning any attempts for forward units to wear and come around in support of those behind.

We only had a morning and afternoon session to play each game and with firing reduced, the battle in the first game was going in favour of the British but more likely after a much more prolonged fight than might otherwise have been. Knowing what I know now, I might leave 'Getting Choppy' out of the chit draw if time to play is limited.

The Wassenaer has her angle of broadside template out to assess when to open fire on the approaching Triumph.

In the afternoon game the chit draw was not so kind to the British and they to managed to get choppy conditions, but this was coupled with an inability to combine their movement and firing into raking passes, later inclining their command to attempt to close, to board opposing Batavian ships, that had not been adequately softened up with broadsides, and not unsurprisingly seeing British boarding parties driven back by stalwart Batavian crews.

Further along the line the first British ships have broken through and are engaging to leeward whilst also returning the salute from the smaller Batavian ships.

A fire has broken out aboard the British flagship Venerable, that was extinguished in the next turn

That said despite the problems imposed on the gunnery attacks by the weather, KMH still produced its drama with the odd fire breaking out here and there and several high officer casualties suffered that would eventually cause a successful strike test to result on one Batavian ship of the line.

Venerable, extreme right is in the thick of the battle with Staten Generaal, now having put out an earlier fire but dealing with a shot away helm as the 'Out of Control' marker suggests.

Even some of the Batavian frigates corvettes, and brigs opened fire as the British broke in among their lines, and were in the main saved by the choppy conditions.

The Lancaster 64-guns, Isis 50-guns and Belliqueux 64-guns, bear down on the Batavian line having successfully rolled to break it and pass through to leeward.

These battles within a battle make for great ways of exploring these historical actions and make for great club games for several players to take commands within each group of opposing ships, and I will likely take this one along to club and attach a copy of the briefing I prepared in the wake of Clotted Lard adding the alterations based on that play test, together with the ship record cards for printing out to get playing straight away, provided you have your models ready to go.

There is a link below for the scenario PDF.

JJ's Wargames - Kiss Me Hardy Scenario, Nailing the Colours

In terms of victory conditions, I include the usual break-off rules to assess win or loss, but in the actual fight, the Batavians put up strong resistance with the flagship Vrijheid fighting for about an hour and losing several masts in the process, only striking with the arrival of the British reinforcements relatively fresh from their fight with the Batavian rear.

If you translate the approximate time scale of KMH to two minutes per move this equates to thirty turns, however I tend to work with a four minute battle time scale, incorporating ideas about a sliding time scale based on varying winds and ship movements that averages the move time to about a four minute move.

If you have the luxury of fighting over a longer time, then I would work to fifteen turns as a maximum scenario length in which time it is assumed the British reinforcements have arrived. If the Batavians are still fighting with no break-off inflicted then they have matched De Winter's result and a game victory, if they have caused a British ship to strike and are still fighting that should equate to an outright victory otherwise the British should be accorded the win at their end of the line, probably after a hard fight if history is anything to go by.

As a postscript I only had one battle damage casualty from our two games, my little 32-gun Batavian frigate Heldin.

The 32-gun fifth rate Heldin undergoing repairs in the riggers yard following Clotted Lard

The loss of the fore jib resulted in the model being manoeuvred by holding the bowsprit and causing the stay to break. Nothing to worry about as these are wargaming models not museum pieces.

'Ship-Shape' and 'Bristol-Fashion'

I've run lots of games now with these models, and generally they prove very robust to handling, and like their historical counterparts are amenable to repair to rigging as required as seen here twenty-four hours later and ready for the NWS meeting at the FAA Museum, Yeovilton next Saturday, and, as they say 'the show goes on'.

I'm off on my travels again soon and this coming weekend in the next run-out for the Camperdown Collection we will have the whole thing out on the table as we prepare to play The Battle of Camperdown with all fifty models at the NWS Meeting at the Fleet Air Arm Museum, Yeovilton, this time using David Manley's rules, 'Far Distant Ships', so if you fancy a day out seeing the fantastic collection and displays in the museum, your access will also enable you to come along and see the naval wargames on show as well.

As always I will post an AAR with plenty of pictures of the day together with a look at the other naval games on show.

Plus I will be looking back to this time last year and my Bantry Bay scenario with another post looking at the Bantry Bay cannons at Cardiff Castle, courtesy of Ollie after Carolyn's and my trip up to the Welsh capital last week to visit her and Will, so more to come here on JJ's.

As always more anon

JJ 

All at Sea - Sercey off Sumatra, Clotted Lard 2022

 

Last weekend I was taking part in Clotted Lard and was running Sercey off Sumatra, one of the fifty historical scenarios that I have pulled together specifically for use with Kiss Me Hardy, with the two games run at the meeting adding to the two previous play tests run as warm-ups in preparation and featured here on the blog.

With players familiar with Kiss Me Hardy but less so with the material I have pulled together, this was a great opportunity to see what other KMH fans thought of the scenario and the materials I have created around it as well as seeing how two different groups of players would respond to the situation it creates based on the historical one faced by Rear Admiral Sercey and Commodore Lucas.

I have pulled together a detailed AAR of the game I ran with the second game in the afternoon overseen by my co-host and fellow gamemeister, Charley Walker, who kindly stepped in while I did my usual coverage of the other games at the show. If you would like to see more of the show as a whole then you can follow the link below for a post on the Devon Wargames Group Blog detailing Clotted Lard 2022.

Devon Wargames Group - Clotted Lard 2022

The table all set up ready to go in the Meeting Room at our new venue for Clotted Lard, Lympstone Village Hall

With the table all set up and ready to go, I briefed the first three players for the game, and we rolled dice to sort out the commands, with two players running the French, Chris, who ran Sercey and the first three frigates in the sailing order and Simon who brought up the rearward three, leaving Neil to to assume the role of Commodore Lucas aboard the Arrogant.

 

I now have a standard kit for running my KMH games that includes my gunnery templates, turning circles, wind compass, laser pen, range sticks, dice towers, activation chits, game specific markers and red and blue dice (d6s and a d10). Here all set up ready to go.

As detailed to the players, the scenario sees Sercey's frigate line off the Sumatran coast protecting a captured British Indiaman prize, (off table), and with the line slightly staggered to allow the second group of three rearward frigates to potentially double the approaching British third rates.

As in the previous play throughs the French detached into their two groups of three and also similarly, the two British third rates looked to sail close to the wind and bear down on the French rear, hoping to deal with them before the French van could come around in support, requiring them to tack back to do so if they did.

Sercey leads the first three frigates into the attack with the second group in close support, as the British attempt to close on the rear most group of Frenchman.

I guess you could call this a ranging shot as both sides were keen to check the likely closing distance prior to opening fire

The action commenced on turn four as the Arrogant 74-guns opens fire on the Régénérée 40-guns leading the nearest group of frigates

The French commander has to be wary of his force being attacked and beaten in detail and it looked as if they might be as the Arrogant opened fire first on the the French rear, causing hits on the more fragile French hulls, soon joined by Victorious adding to the hurt.

The Victorious 74-guns lends her fire in support of the flagship as the Cybèle 40-guns lends her support to the Régénérée ahead of her.

Battle well and truly on as the lead frigate in the French van, Vertu (nearest camera) unleashes a devastatingly accurate extreme range broadside aimed at Victorious' rigging (extreme right), bringing down the third rate's main-mast and causing the first strike test of the game, easily passed by the British ship as, with a cheer, the fallen mast and rigging was cleared.

As if sensing a potential problem about to start, Sercey had his van come across the rear of the Victorious at extreme range to start to deliver fire at the British rigging, an historic tactic that KMH encourages the French to do, giving them extra dice with their firing, even though they have to hit on a '6'.

Rather surprisingly the lead frigate, Vertu managed to cause several hits on the British third rate and also managed to include a low score on the D10 that signified a potential critical hit on the rigging of Victorious.

The subsequent die roll revealed a damaging strike on the British ship's mainmast, bringing it down, immediately knocking off several speed boxes and requiring the the third-rate to take a strike test, made slightly more problematic, with the inclusion of 'High Officer Casualties', thus increasing the chances of failure.

The Arrogant starts to pull away from her consort as she looks to close on the French rearmost group before Sercey can come up in support

The strike test on Victorious was duly taken and passed with a rousing cheer from the British crew, but seeing the gap between the two British ships widen as with her damaged rigging Victorious was unable to keep up with the now sleek Arrogant knifing through the water like a predatory shark; intent on dealing a death blow to the weakest French frigate in the rear most group, the 32-gun Prudente, now badly damaged by successive broadsides from the advancing third-rate.

The range is now down to long and both sides are focussing their fire, with the French aiming at British rigging

HMS Arrogant bears down on the 32-gun Prudente, and with the range decreasing, starts to work over the small French frigate as the trailing Victorious bears the brunt of support fire from the French. 

The Arrogant was irresistible as she got the drop on the French rear, being able to move and fire simultaneously, whilst passing in close to the stern galleries of the Prudente to enable a grapple as a punishing stern rake finished off the target, not requiring the Royal Marines to storm onto the French deck, but rather to help lower boats to pick up survivors from the sinking frigate.

The moment of decision as the Arrogant passes close on the Prudente's stern galleries and grapples whilst pouring in a point-blank stern rake.

With the Victorious now badly damaged aloft and under heavy fire from Sercey's remaining frigates, the Arrogant dispatches Prudente to the bottom with a second point-blank stern rake, to allow her to break contact and come to the support of her consort.

Victorious top left is under heavy fire as Sercey brings up his van to support his rear. Meanwhile Arrogant has dispatched the Prudente and is picking up survivors as she prepares to come up in support

Meanwhile the Victorious bravely battled away against the fire of four Frenchman, as the Arrogant sought to come to her aide and reduce the number of enemies, by turning in towards the next frigate in line, the  Cybèle, who now found herself with the third-rate bearing down on her starboard bow, with likely aggressive intent.

The action is now a general fight as formation struggles to be maintained and the firing is close 

Again the British flagship was able to conjure up a combination of move, fire and grapple, with a bow rake being the preferred modus-operandi on this occasion, and with the grapples in place seeing a strike test marker laid ready to test at the appropriate time.

As if on cue, the Strike Test chit appeared almost immediately after, and was failed, seeing the Frenchman haul down his colours, before any British boarders had climbed over their own bulwarks.

The Arrogant has closed in on a second French frigate, the Cybèle, second from left and crossed her bows whilst delivering a point-blank rake and successfully grappling her. A strike test marker is against a starboard stern gallery to remind us to test when the chit is drawn. Meanwhile the Victorious continues her heroic struggle with three other Frenchman as she comes up in support, but taking heavy damage aloft as she does.

With our morning session fast approaching lunch time, having played through about sixteen turns of play, and now with 33% of the French squadron out of action and plenty of fight still left in the British force, we called the game in favour of Commodore Lucas.

The following ship records tell their own story, with the Arrogant barely having a scratch on her paintwork, but with the Victorious having borne the brunt of French aggression badly damaged in her rigging, but only lightly damaged on her hull, leaving her still in a formidable state as a fighting gun platform.

Commodore (Captain) Richard Lucas - Arrogant (flagship)

As far as Sercey's command, the cards reveal the frustrating morning endured by the French (Simon, we all felt your pain!), only relieved by the administering of the extreme range dismasting of the Victorious but leaving all the surviving French frigates except the Vertu carrying light damage, likely to cause the French commander to seek repairs rather than persist with his campaign into the Indian Ocean.

Rear-Admiral de Sercey -  Forte (flagship)

Thank you to all the players and to our several guests who joined us to watch what proved to be a highly entertaining fight and underlined what an interesting and challenging little action this is for both sides.