It part one of this three part series looking at my preparations for playing the Battle of Cape St Vincent in time for the 225th Anniversary of the battle, I looked at the time line of events leading up to the Battle of Cape St Vincent which you can refer back to in the link below:
JJ's Wargames - The St Vincent Campaign, October 1796 to February 1797 |
![]() |
JJ's Wargames - The Planning and Preparation for the 225th Anniversary Game of Cape St Vincent (Part I) |
Why would you want to play Trafalgar? |
https://toofatlardies.co.uk/product/2008-christmas-special/ |
However Nick's scenario plan for this game and his suggestions for setting up the respective fleets were my starting point and with further delving into my other references it proved quite an interesting exercise trying to find broad agreement particularly about which Spanish vessels were at the battle and where they were.
The set up map from the 2008 Christmas Lardy Special |
My experience planning Trafalgar and other large games informs me that where you decide to start the game is important as often playing time is limited and the object of the scenario is often to pose the question to players:
'This is what your historic predecessor decided to do and the likely problems he faced. So what are you going to do from here?'
Thus position at or just beyond extreme gunnery range seems a good place to begin, posing an immediate challenge to both commanders likely to be presented with an early opportunity to fire and potentially inflict damage at extreme or long range, but, if doing so, losing that all important first broadside capability that can make the difference at short and point blank ranges.
So when I sit down to work out an initial set up those factors are front and centre of the placement planning process, which often necessitates knowing the ranges that various ships opened fire at at any time to get an idea of placement to commence the game, with the imperative to start matters close to or as near as the moment the fleets had the opportunity to open fire, this to save game time simply moving models on the approach.
Adkin's excellent maps for all of Nelson's battles leading up to Trafalgar are a game planners dream when other sources are contrary and incomplete. |
Adkin's second map shows the battle unfolding, a stage of the scenario that will be left to the respective players |
My set-up map based on Adkins primarily, with Nick Skinner's scenario plan at top |
Another view of my table plan based on my set-up map to get a visual plan of the set-up |
The two 74's, Infante de Pelayo and San Pablo were detached early on the 14th February when the Spanish heard British frigates signalling with gunfire in the morning mist, that they had spotted the Spanish fleet, and the two ships were sent off to investigate at 08.00, leaving Cordoba to fight the upcoming battle without them.
The map showing the movement of the various units during the St Vincent Campaign shows the passage of Cordoba's fleet from Malaga and through the Gibraltar Straits |
Thus with my Spanish order of battle refined I then turned to initial placement as the two fleets closed for battle, with only certain vessels specifically identified in various maps but by no means all the Spanish precisely indicated, rather highlighting the mess they had got themselves into during the turn to a NW heading that Cordoba ordered at 10am, as he set a course for Cadiz as the British double-column approached on his now starboard side
This placement required a bit of educated guesswork using the original organisation lists for Cordoba's fleet that shows which ships were part of which of the three squadrons, namely the rear under Morales aboard the Purisima Concepcion, the centre under Cordoba aboard the Santisima Trinidad and the van under Moreno aboard the Principe de Asturias.
The order of battle is indicated in my fleet listing for the game seen above, and using this together with the known positions of various ships during the battle I started to place all the ships among the two Spanish gaggles based on their previous order of sailing prior to the turn at 10 am and so Cordoba's group have Morales's squadron to the front and Cordoba's behind, with any of Moreno's squadron not with him in his trailing group placed to the rear of Cordoba's lead group with my map showing the planned layout.
The principle change sees commanders having a command range that allows their signals to be seen and interpreted by any ship in their command that falls within that command radius, which is further extended by repeater frigates. Thus frigates have been positioned among the fleets to allow for signalling at the start of the game, as new course headings and tactics will need to be communicated to the respective commands during the game, which should add another level of fun to the proceedings.
With the fleet break point rules in play, the game will change at some point from a battle where both sides are intent on contesting the space to a different game where one side, likely the Spanish, is looking to extract itself and the other is looking to take advantage of the situation with the signalling ability of both fleets being an important component.
So the plan is to play as much of this battle at our club meeting this Saturday and to see if we can get our game to any sort of a conclusion with a follow up post covering all the fun of the day and the drama created together with some thoughts about what worked well and stuff not so well.
Finally, as touched on in my Xmas post, storage and transportability of any collection of models and required sea cloths is important and, if you missed it, you can check out my post in the link below that covers off those key aspects of putting on a game.
JJ's Wargames - All at Sea, The Perennial Challenge of Storage and Terrain |
This aspect of game management was well tested last year with my trip up to Warlord Games in Nottingham to run the Trafalgar Anniversary game and the trusty RUB's and inserts are proving their worth yet again for this weekend's game.
A final check against the fleet list for the Spanish before being put into the boxes. |