O'er the Hills Early Peninsular War Scenario Book

O'er the Hills Early Peninsular War Scenario Book
Just click the banner if you would like to know more about the Kickstarter

Friday, 8 December 2017

The Second Barons War - Simon De Montfort & the Battles of Lewes & Evesham By John Sadler


I bought this book along with some others as part of a special deal Pen & Sword were running recently because it’s a period that isn’t much written about outside of the odd magazine article.

Having visited Lewes during my Great Southern Tour a few years back travelling along the South Coast of England supposedly looking at all the Roman Saxon Shore Forts and Henry VIII’s later versions, I already had an interest in the subject. I remember staring out at yet more empty fields wondering if I was looking at the correct empty fields where the battle had taken place without realising that as normal there is some doubt over what happened where.

The book itself is not that long and although covering both battles and some of the history that goes with the war the author has padded it out a bit.

Chapter one is called Background of Arms and Men and explains what medieval warfare was like in this period together with descriptions of the armour, weapons and sieges; some of it is interesting but it doesn't warrant twenty-six pages.

Chapter 2: The reign of Henry III. Only thirteen pages long and covers Henry's father King John and the reasons why the barons where unhappy with current events, I would have liked to have seen more in this section.


Chapters 3 and 4 cover the battle of Lewes, twenty-eight pages: here the author is on better form and does a good job describing the build up, forces concerned, pre-battle negotiations and then the battle itself. The possible battlefield options are discussed in this chapter and his conclusions are well thought through.


Chapters 5 and 6 Evesham: forty-one pages; again a good section covering both the campaign and the battle itself, there is conjecture on the dispositions and marching routes taken which the author addresses, his reasoning and conclusions are again very sound. This section also covers the attack on Simon’s son in Kenilworth.


Chapter 7 Legacy: an eight page chapter which rounds up events after Evesham.

Appendix 1: Alternative Evesham: Another very short chapter discussing the popular alternatives to what happened and the author’s opinion on them.

Appendix 2 The Battlefield Trail: 6 pages with OS numbers and what to look out for, not really of much use.



Appendix 3: Wargaming the Battles, four paragraphs: nice to see but totally useless. The book ends with a Glossary of terms including things such as Broadsword, Helm and Bolt.

Chapter Notes with some extra material included, I enjoy these types of notes rather than just the normal document references. which lets be honest I will never use but I do like extra information that expands on topics.

Index.

That is probably the shortest review I have done and I padded out the start.

It’s a mixed bag, the battles themselves are well done but there isn't really that much that the author can use to expand on, his best section is when he goes over the campaigns and his diagnosis of possible events which is very good. He first explains all the options, then gives the two main views held and explains his reason for why he chose what he did.

Outside of that the rest isn't that interesting, there are current day location photos and the sketch maps are OK.

As I said I bought this book as part of a deal and I paid around £15 for it, a week later it was on special offer for £8. If it’s still at £8 then its worth getting as there is not a lot else out there which covers this period. If Medieval Warfare ever does an issue on the Second Barons war then that might be a better idea.

Also I haven’t yet bought the new Osprey Campaign (£14.99) which covers these two battles so cannot give you a comparison. (I see Amazon have it in stock for £10.03)

https://www.amazon.co.uk/Lewes-Evesham-1264-65-Montfort-Campaign/dp/147281150X

Death of De Montfort

Finally for the thousands of you out there wondering, Simon De Montfort was the younger son of Simon De Montfort of the Albigensian crusades fame for which an award winning review of a book covering his interesting life is available elsewhere on this blog.(Well I thought it was good)

JJ Note: Yes so did I and here is the link.
http://jjwargames.blogspot.co.uk/2017/02/kill-them-all-cathars-and-carnage-in.html

Hardback and Kindle
Readable pages 143 out of 160
RRP of £19.99 ,
Best price 30th Nov 2017 = £8.00+p&p Pen & Sword

This has been a Mr Steve presentation

8 comments:

  1. Nice review, not a period I'm currently doing but I won't rule it out someday!
    Best Iain

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks for the review--remember reading about the Baronial Wars in Oman's "Art of War in the Middle Ages."

    ReplyDelete
  3. Sounds great, a beautiful presentation...in a very interesting century, so many things to tell about Simon De Montfort!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Thanks everyone , there is some description on the political situation that forced the Barons to rebel but I do wish the author had gone into much more detail on this.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Good review "Mr Steve". A pity the book is not so strong, as I am interested in this period. I must say I knew much of what the book seems to cover. Maybe there really isn't much more information available, as is often the case so far back in time.

    Vince

    ReplyDelete
  6. Nice review. Does it suffer from the usual Pen & Sword issue of plentiful typos?

    ReplyDelete
  7. The author is strongest when he evaluates the possible options for army movement or deployments and all his conclusions appeared very well reasoned to me.
    I mentioned there is a new Osprey covering the same subject which should be able to adequately cover the two battles and the associated campaigns in its normal 96 pages given what little information is available to us .I also have Oman’s Art of War so I will go back and re-read the relevant section and see what he says on these events.
    I agree,Pen and Sword can be a bit hit and miss but fortunately both this book and the one I reviewed recently on Aurelian did not suffer noticeably from poor proof reading.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks. I'll be putting this one on the "maybe" list (so many books, so little time).

      Delete