O'er the Hills Early Peninsular War Scenario Book

O'er the Hills Early Peninsular War Scenario Book
Just click the banner if you would like to know more about the Kickstarter

Wednesday, 5 April 2017

The English Civil War 1642-1651, An Illustrated History - Philip Haythornthwaite


In my series of posts last month covering our weekend trip to Oxford and the local sites I mentioned that as part of my look at Edgehill and Cropredy Bridge, having certain books in hand to reference the history about those battles.

One such book is one I have had on my bookshelf for a good few years now, but one I had always dipped into but never read cover to cover. However with our trip planned I felt compelled to do so and thought I would share my thoughts about it.

My copy of 'The English Civil War' is a first edition from 1983 and I see from looking at the references to it on the net that it has been reprinted several times which I think illustrates its value as over the years since it was first published.

If I were to characterise the contents, it reads rather like a substantial Osprey title with a text that takes the reader through the politics and history of events that cover the first, second and third civil war with an analysis of the politics that lead up to the outbreak of hostilities, the organisation and tactics of the armies together with, the highlight of the book, the colour illustrations based on artwork and descriptions from contemporary work.

The contents
1. The road to civil war
2. The armies
3. Organisation, equipment and tactics - Foot, Horse, Artillery, Engineers, Tactics
4. The First Civil War 1642-3
5. The First Civil War 1644
6. New Model: The First Civil War 1645
7. Between the First and Second Civil Wars 1646-7
8. The Second Civil War 1648
9. The Third Civil War 1649-51
10. Uniforms
11. Colours and standards
Appendix: Medals
Notes
Glossary
Select bibliography

Two of the eighty illustrations that fill this book and make it such a great reference for the wargamer

The colour plates of which there are eighty illustrations of troop types from the period together with thirteen examples of colours carried by infantry and cavalry are great inspiration and reference for the wargamer/painter and the text is lavishly illustrated with black and white illustrations, photographs of surviving arms and armour and contemporary maps of the various key battles.

This book is intended, and I think fulfils the role, as a solid base reference for the war, which from comments on other sites seems to have stood the test of time. As with an Osprey title you will need to read further books with greater substance to gain a deeper understanding of the events described.

If I were to fault the book it would centre around a lack of good battle maps and in the first edition copy I have, Edgehill doesn't have a title to it, although as my post on the battlefield illustrated our understanding of the layout for that battle has changed with the information gleaned from modern archaeological techniques.

So in summary, despite the age of this tome, it is still a very handy reference to have and one that would appear to be still obtainable second hand for about a tenner.

5 comments:

  1. Me too, i've the first ediction of this great book !! all the best, ciao carlo

    ReplyDelete
  2. Agree - it's a terrific general reference, and avoids the overall bias of some of the Received Histories. It is sometimes referred to as "a bit old fashioned", which may be construed as "not published by Partizan", but let us rise above that.

    Mr Haythornthwaite has produced a number of very useful books over the years - I am all in favour of his efforts. This particular work, along with most of the humble little Stuart Press booklets, has been invaluable to me, and I think they are underappreciated.

    ReplyDelete
  3. It's a great book, I got the library to order it when it came out, I've had 3 copies so far, having loaned /lost and given away 2 hardback copies I've got the paperback, I echo MSFOY in that Mr Haythornthwaite has written a number of good books, most of the rest I have are napoleonic and he has a nice clear balanced writing style. I've also heard it described as old fashioned but I think it's a lovely book.
    Best Iain

    ReplyDelete
  4. Thanks for your comments chaps. It's always reassuring to see what you think is a good reference is validated by others.

    I too have many other books by Philip Haythornthwaite and like you, they form a solid core to my library, particularly for the horse and musket period and I wouldn't be without them.

    Hopefully our comments will sign post a new generation of historical gamers to these 'older' but no less valuable works of reference.

    Cheers
    JJ

    ReplyDelete