O'er the Hills Early Peninsular War Scenario Book

O'er the Hills Early Peninsular War Scenario Book
Just click the banner if you would like to know more about the Kickstarter

Tuesday, 20 May 2014

Wellington against Massena - David Buttery


Last month I posted my thoughts about Peter Edwards book Albuera and why it had taken me so long to finish reading it. Well I took my own advice and got my IPad use under control and am now able to share my thoughts about the next book from my library.

This is the second  David Buttery book I have read, the first one I posted about last September was Wellington against Junot.

I was going to go through the chapters and my thoughts about them and then I read the review from the Napoleon Series.

Napoleon Series - Wellington Against

The review says everything I would including the reference to Imperial Guard infantry being put into the fighting for Fuentes, very silly.

That being said, I found the book a very entertaining read if not the forensic study of the battles I usually prefer in my history. The lack of orders of battle is an interesting omission in a book on this subject matter. Not a problem if like me and most other wargamers you have access to copies of orders of battle for this campaign but not very helpful for the casual reader trying to understand how the two armies were arranged.

I think the part of the book I found most interesting was the chapter on Massena's earlier career and the victory at Zurich causing the capture of 70,000 prisoners and beating two great captains of the period, Suvorov and the Archduke Charles, eclipsing Bonaparte and his disastrous adventure to Egypt. The description of a general prepared to wait for the right opportunity to strike fitted in with the description of the much older man that led the French forces into Portugal but was still able to show flashes of the brilliance demonstrated in his earlier career.

It is interesting to read about the high esteem he was held in by Wellington, who always considered him to have been the best of the Marshals he came up against in the Peninsula; and when they eventually met in Paris after the war are reported to have got on famously, exchanging compliments on each others performance in the 1810-11 campaign. This despite the differences in social class the two men came from. It was obviously the measure of Massena as a commander that overcame any such  issues in the eyes of Wellington.

The situation that Massena found himself in when he very reluctantly took the command of the third invasion of Portugal was very unenviable. The nature of dictatorships from Napoleon to Hitler means that these leaders only feel secure in their positions when they have all their subordinates competing with each other. Thus it was in the Peninsula, where Napoleon never gave supreme command to any of his commanders, and thus cooperation between forces became problematic. Massena was unable to order Soult to support his invasion as the latter should have done, and had problems getting Ney to obey the simplest orders. The last insult was having the insolent commander of the Guard Cavalry, Lepic at Fuentes, disobey an order to complete the attack on Wellington's disrupted flank, by claiming that he only took orders from Marshal Bessieres, whose whereabouts at the time was unknown and thus the battle opportunity was lost. I really came to the conclusion that if I had been serving Napoleon in that role I would have taken a young mistress on campaign as well.

Wellington knew full well that Fuentes was so nearly a defeat with the Duke having over extended his right flank and he was candid enough to admit it after the war. As he went on to say about the battle that if Bonaparte had been there then he would have been beat. I think this comment reflects not on any lack of talent on Massena's part but more the fact that Napoleon would have had the full cooperation of the Marshals that Massena was never able to rely on.

I came away from this book with a much deeper regard for Marshal Andrea Massena and a greater appreciation for why Wellington considered him as "their best".

If like me you are interested in the character of these two great commanders during this very important campaign then this book is well worth the read.

4 comments:

  1. Always enjoy your Napoloenics work. I nominated you for a Liebster Award http://palousewargamingjournal.blogspot.com/2014/05/leibster-nomination.html.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Jon, thank you and congratulations to you to. Keep blogging

      Delete
  2. I was unaware of this book, however I believe I'll need to pick it up. Last year I finished Napoleon & Wellington by Andrew Roberts. Instead of focusing on their military careers alone, it focuses on their private lives and their attitudes towards each other and the men around them. Wellington can be accused of envying Napoleon by all of the actions he took after the war to take Napoleon's mistresses and such,

    Fuentes de Onoro is one of my favorite battles because it was so close it could have gone either way. I often thought if I were Massena after the battle, I would have asked to meet with Bessieres and place him in irons and escort him from Spain in shame and let Napoleon deal with the fallout. Surely the guard cavalry present (no infantry) felt somewhat shamed in that they were forced to sit and watch the battle be lost.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Vl'E, I think it is clear that Wellington had a sincere regard for Napoleon, but was clearly conscious of the threat his ideas posed to his social class. Mark Urban's excellent book about Scovell, who broke the French codes in the Peninsular War, shows the barriers to advancement that were present in an army commanded by Wellington, given the Duke's suspicion of professional officers who he considered were the epitome of Napoleonic ideas in British society. Wellington always felt it was just as important to be a "gentleman" as it was to have ability, which is why it was surprising to see how well he got on with Massena.
      I think Fuentes was a battle too late for Massena and he knew that his reputation was so low in the eyes of the Emperor that only a victory would be enough to secure his position. Once the battle was lost, attempting to take action against officers who had been partly responsible for that failure would have been futile and he knew it. Better to retire quietly with some honour still intact. In the end he got what he desired, a quiet job away from campaigning and time to enjoy the fruits of his previous employment.

      Delete